Your team spent weeks—maybe months—negotiating an important transaction. Someone, possibly not the deal lawyers, chose arbitration over the courts as a last-minute clause before signing. Now a dispute has arisen, arbitration is looming, it may last more than a year at significant cost, and you must select an arbitrator. Outside counsel will present candidates, and your instinct may be to defer to them—but don’t. Selecting an arbitrator isn’t a legal formality. It’s the equivalent of hiring …
Articles by Fellows
The Silicon Arbiter: AI-Generated Arbitration Awards and the Federal Arbitration Act – Part II
The emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) systems has made urgent a question that would have seemed absurd to the drafters of the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA): whether algorithms might generate binding arbitral awards without human involvement. This two-part article concludes that, under the FAA as currently written, such awards cannot be enforced. Yet this article does not end with a negative prognosis for AI’s place in arbitration. Instead, it makes suggestions for legislative reform …
What Arbitrators Actually Think About Your Expert
Republished with permission from JAMS. What is and is not effective expert testimony Unlike a jury, an arbitrator is rarely seeing anything for the first time. That changes everything. Experienced arbitrators have heard hundreds of experts — they recognize the theater, they spot the evasions, and they dislike witnesses who sacrifice credibility for advocacy. The qualities that make an expert effective before an arbitrator are not always the same qualities that resonate with a jury. Over …
Feliu Case Summaries, June 2026
Prepared by Alfred Feliu, a Fellow of the College of Commercial Arbitrators, the Feliu Case Summaries (June 2026) provide a practical snapshot of notable, recent decisions shaping arbitration and ADR across U.S. federal and state courts. Organized by topic, the digest highlights key developments affecting arbitration agreements, threshold jurisdictional disputes, delegation and waiver arguments, unconscionability challenges, class and representative action issues, hearing and evidentiary …
Arbitrating the Mediated Term Sheet
By Renee Gerstman Congratulations! The mediation was successful and the parties executed a term sheetsetting forth the substantive terms to be included in a formal definitive agreement. The parties,intending the term sheet to be binding despite lack of executed final settlement documents,1include a sentence providing that the mediator will resolve any disputes regarding the mediatedterm sheet. In the process of finalizing the settlement agreement a dispute arises, and the mediator isasked …
Commentary: Why Arbitrators Could Not Stay Silent
There is a well-known confession attributed to Pastor Martin Niemöller, the German clergyman who survived the Nazi concentration camps. He described, with devastating simplicity, how he said nothing when the Nazis came for the socialists, said nothing when they came for the trade unionists, said nothing when they came for the Jews — and then found, when they came for him, that there was no one left to speak. The College of Commercial Arbitrators cited that confession in the amicus brief it filed …
A Report on Corporate Counsel Arbitration Preferences
This report summarizes the results of a survey of corporate counsel from leading U.S. companies attending the 2026 CPR Annual Meeting in Coronado, California. The survey was conducted in collaboration with the College of Commercial Arbitrators during the authors’ interactive Feb. 13 program, “Corporate Counsel Vote!” The voting was conducted confidentially by electronic polling in a closed session of about 20 corporate counsel, all of whom are well informed and actively involved in arbitration …
The Silicon Arbiter: AI-Generated Arbitration Awards and the Federal Arbitration Act – Part I
The emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) systems has made urgent a question that would have seemed absurd to the drafters of the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA): whether algorithms might generate binding arbitral awards without human involvement. This two-part article concludes that, under the FAA as currently written, such awards cannot be enforced. Yet this article does not end with a negative prognosis for AI’s place in arbitration. Instead, it makes suggestions for legislative reform …
The Federal Arbitration Act at 100 and the New York Connection
In 2025 and 2026, we celebrate the centenary of the Federal Arbitration Act and the birth of the American Arbitration Association. These tandem events are no coincidence. These twin celebrations present the rare opportunity to examine the relationship and recognize the central contribution of visionary and strategic New York lawyers to today’s vastly expanded world of alternative dispute resolution that was built on the foundation they established. (Reprinted with permission from the April …
Why Arbitration Depends on Legal Independence
Arbitration and the rule of law are interdependent. Arbitration is a private, contract-based mechanism for resolving disputes. From the merchant guilds of medieval Europe to the arbitration clauses embedded in modern domestic and international contracts, and state-to-state disputes, the practice has thrived because it is perceived as efficient, trustworthy, rule-based, and neutral. (Reprinted with permission from the April 2026 edition of the New Jersey Lawyer Magazine ©2026 New Jersey State …
